Join music gear discussions on Equipboard. Talk about guitar gear, electronic music production, get help identifying gear, ask for feedback on your music, suggest ideas to improve Equipboard and more.

Help choosing a bridge pickup

I've been thinking about building a guitar, and am at a standstill when it comes to deciding on a bridge pickup. I'm stuck between the Dimarzio Super 2, Dimarzio Notorious Minibucker, and Seymour Duncan Antiquity P90. I'm hoping to make the guitar versatile, but I personally mostly play Classic and Math Rock, and Alternative, with a hint of Metal. I'm panning to make the mid and neck p'ups Seymour Duncan Five-Two Strat's.

GEAR:
  • Vox AC15
  • Gibson ES 335 Studio Dirty Fingers Plus
  • Ernie Ball Power Slinky Guitar Strings (11-48)

Ya can't go wrong with DiMarzios. I've got original Super Distortions in my Lotus L-400 (red guitar under my name), they bloody rock. Super 2s are kind of the reverse, more top end, less bass, and the Notorious is kind of even across the field. A P90 is a totally different beast. So that's three very different sounds, just depends on if you want more top end boost, really. Can't say I know much about the SD P90, not a fan of SD pickups myself (even though my current favorite guitarist uses them--I just... I don't like 'em), but if they're like other vintage voiced P90s, it'd be kind of equal overall, just a bit top heavy.

So taking that info together, you've got three pickups, two that skew top heavy, one that's more even keel, so you seem to be tacking towards the treble side of things. If you're going for balanced overall, the P90's EQ values line up closest with the Five Twos, whereas the Super 2s just bring a lot more top end. The Notorious actually roll some of that top end back, and bring a little more low end.

That's basing everything off of what the EQ charts say--not actually listening to soundclips or what have you, bit of a migraine right now--bad weather in my area. But should give you an idea of where to go with it.

GEAR:
  • Vox V241 Bulldog
  • Kay KDG 70
  • Lotus/Morris L-400 Falcon Guitar

Thanks again! I think I might go with the Notorious just to balance things out a bit more. Hope your migraine clears up soon.

GEAR:
  • Vox AC15
  • Gibson ES 335 Studio Dirty Fingers Plus
  • Ernie Ball Power Slinky Guitar Strings (11-48)

Soon as the weather passes, I'll be bene, but thank you!

The Notorious, I believe is what Tim Henson of Polyphia uses, so for math rock, that should work, and work well. And should balance it out pretty good, too.

GEAR:
  • Vox V241 Bulldog
  • Kay KDG 70
  • Lotus/Morris L-400 Falcon Guitar

consider a duncan that splits the difference between P90 tone and hot rod humbucker, the 59/custom hybrid :-)

GEAR:
  • Roland Juno-6
  • Gibson SG Standard
  • Vox AC30 Guitar Combo Amp