I justs tarted talking at you and it kept going:
I wouldn't call the pricneton reverb a budget fender, vintage examples are starting to cost as much or more than an original deluxe reverb.... I actually prefer the non-reverb models, both brown and black/silver to the reverbs event hough i sued to play reverbs. Now the non-reverbs are still a deal in vintage fender! And if you aren't a reerb junky they sound clearer and brekup with more crunch and less swamp. I had a friend who owned like 2 from every cosmetic including some white knobs and brownfaces which are awesome though i really kinda slant towards th brown deluxe for small bownface tone. Anyway, I guess you cna tell I am not a huge reverb guy unless I am playing jazz. For rockin' rock, even playing clean, i don't want any cloudy bullshit. Slapback or ping pong delays to me feel way better and clearer. Guys who double up delay and reverb are straight up nuts. What you can do to a recorded guitar in a mix is totally different than what you can pump into the frnt end or even what you can get away with in an FX loop. Anyway, i gotta tell ya that a well serviced vintage princeton easily make 15 watts clean power, man. Use a sesitive speaker (I had an old JBL in mine) and it can hang in any situation but super loud rock bands. Al though I sued one in every rock band Iw as in in highschool, just turned way up into overdrive and Iw as the only guitarist, always trios back then. But you might wanna check it out, you could run it at 5 right ebfore it breaks up versus 3 on the super reverb which is a little below where the reissues start to soudn respectable. Tools for the job, man. If you wanted to get all power tube drive I would say to get an ac4 for a church gig! If I were allowed to play in churches (I don't kow if I am allowed in them) I would be a dick and brng one of my EL34 amps and disconnect the volume control. Iw as always talking about doing that with my superleads because I ahted when soundmen would ltierally walk up and grab my volume control at sound check in rinky dink venues! And they did even though I usually had an attenuator in line just in case. Its like the lsoer soundmen at small clubs in like Maryland or North Carolina didn't get what the hot palte did back then. instead f asking me to take another 2 bD off they just walked up in a huff. I almost hit one guy. I knocked his ahdn away because I ahd decided to take out a vintage amp as my main amp instead of the '88 reissue and I know I said soemthing like "don't even touch that volume knob or your grubby figners will hurt the resale on this! Don't you know its blasphemy to play a 60s marshall below 9? I thought this was a ROCK music club!" I'm sure we got a lousy mix that night but I ahd asked him to keep me outta the PA and he miced me anyway. I just wanted to rip it and use the PA for vocals and some drum reinforceement and maybe some extra sub for the bass.
my 'new-waviest' (I like that word, you can use it) band was in highschool, also used a princeton reverb with a JBL alnico speaker, back up was eventually a princeton reverb with a JBL ceramic, ibanez chorus, boss flanger, tubescreamer and that was it for a long time. Played at 5 to 6 I think. Semi hollow with coil tappable buckers so i ahd a wide range at that elvel and even wider with the OD aailable for lead boost. But I definitely didn't just cop cure tones or anything, iw as doing my own thing with those modualtion pedals. I don't think I sued the ampreverb in that group. Anyway. You can do anything you (blake) wanna do with that set up. As long as there's a strong PA or the room is small with a quiet audience.
On the other hand, as loud as a vox is, its the right volume for so many situations because the sweet spot is super wide for clean and it'll start breaking up at a surprisingly reasonable volume, you justa ren't getting to gain-banger territory at low levels without soemthing in line. I do find that even a 30 watt vox tends to peak out at a point that will make some sounden groumble but its not unbearable, you know? After that it gets moredistorted and comrpessed but not much louder.
A lot depends on your attack. i find I sound more distorted than like anyone else I know through the same gear at the same settings with the same guitar. Its realy weird because my right hand is really controlled and I don't fret very hard. But for some reason what comes out of the guitar jack is super high voltage. Its really weird. There are so many people who tell me that with a plexi at 10 they can't get past acdc levels and I am shocked because every different superlead I ahd would get past acdc at 9 for me just right off the shelf the day I bought it. soemtiems at 8! It'd be in a 80s hard rock territory with anything stronger than a 60s style strat, no pedals. Its soemthing about how I play. I know it wasn't always the case because when i went from princetons and amster volume amrshalls in the alte 90s to superleads I ahd a lot of trouble for a couple years and then after while it clicked and now every amp seems to wanna give up the goods for me. The small amps seem to roll over and fetch now too. But these days I have a lot of trouble with overdrive pedals. Even 'transparent ones. I have one I really like right now and its all rpeset in for soemthing subtle that melds with the amps, and yet its not great for everything and it just ruins my tone soetimes or eats a great lick. I play into an OD and its a mess. Boosts I do fine with but they are looking for an amp that's dirtier (read louder) so its not managing things like an OD where its doing a smidge of boosting but bringing a little dirt to the party along with the voltage jump. One thing I always loved about OD versus clean boosts is that classic ODs have some tone shaping. Many of them roll off too much bass for my taste and don't put it back but if you use them as always on pedals they work wodners at helping you cut a mix and over the eyars I've gotten away from boosts that are flat or trying to be flat and have embraced treble boosters, mid-boosters, the boos fet bost, dod bifet preamp, the echoplex, the dynacomp, EQ pedals and the colorsund overdriver/power-booster. They all have tone controls or a built in EQ curve and that's the shit. Right now I kinda go abck and forth between the gasdget I built which sits between a brian may treble booster and soemthing likethe echoplex or boss fet preamp or I sue whatever is in my ABY switcher whch si really nice, has a mid only boost with 2 fixed mid humps boosts or a fully variable gain boost where you cna click in one of the 2 mid hums or go flat. I like to do just a few dB of gain and a mid boost to get my thang going. Tightens everything up, gets a little extra out of the first stage distrtion wise adding soem swirl to the sound I guess. Or grind? dunno. WHatever you would call it. So on your original point, if you are going to gauge down to a princeton tog et it to the edge of breaup on stage at church then I woudl say boost, but not a clean one. I would find an always on type of boost with some shape, try the EP boost or the dunlop echoplex maybe. And I would work the volume control to get different shades. Or stick adynacomp before it with the comrepssion up and the elvel down if you wnnna keep your ssutain clean and also not ahve to reach down for the volume all the time. I think this amp-based approach will be less of a rabit hole for you. Boost at the back of your signal chain, even maybe after your delay. I think the transparent thing will give you grief. Nothing si transparent and I find that once you start to extract a lot of juice from that 1sts tage it sounds funny unless you DO have soe eq in the voltage increasing device. Even a little 5dB lift can make your tone all funky with weird harmonics. A lot of tiems guys are like "wow that soudns rgeat" with those boosty soudns ut then they get in the band and thigns sound funky and they dislike it after that or the band dislikes it LOL