Submitted Duplicate

Submitted by mzc2001 about 3 years ago

Keep:

Graph Tech Black TUSQ XL Nut
Graph Tech Black TUSQ XL Nut
Miscellaneous Guitar Parts Graph Tech
Artists: 0
Reviews: 1

Merge:

Graph Tech BLACK TUSQ XL Jazz Bass Nut
Graph Tech BLACK TUSQ XL Jazz Bass Nut
Miscellaneous Guitar Parts Graph Tech
Artists: 0
Reviews: 0

Denied by ttinari about 3 years ago

Comment to re-open this submission. Make sure to provide as much evidence as possible as to why these items are duplicates and should be merged.

Comments 5

Sign Up or Log In to comment

dimensiomat
dimensiomat
290

not dublicate, since one is bass and one is 6 string guitar

I think the most appropriate way to catalogue this item is to focus on the line (Graph Tech Black TUSQ XL Nut) rather than on the specific models for guitar, bass, ukes, multi-scale instruments, etc.; as all these nuts share exactly the same characteristics and composition.

It is worth mentioning that there are also a multitude of models with different sizes for each instrument, so I think it is more efficient to generalize to avoid this kind of problems.

dimensiomat
dimensiomat
290

I see no problem in having several listed, but I do understand now why it was seen as dublicate; should the listing than not be the series in general and not the guitar one? one item representing a series has its own problems, since I would not list it as having it, reviewing it or an artist using it since its not the same item

The thing is that the first article actually DOES refer to the series; I suppose the misunderstanding comes from the fact that the photograph in the article shows a guitar nut, for no specific reason and being the instrument for which the greatest variety of models of this nut exist :)

dimensiomat
dimensiomat
290

you are right, I only commented since it was two items, most players know about it and since they use PTFE I haven't used it