That's great feedback. For a long time, the bread and butter of the site has been associating gear with pro artists, though that process isn't exactly lightweight since the proof and explanation require some level of thought & care. As the site evolves it's becoming more about helping people find kick-ass gear, pro artists or not. And in that sense you can contribute by adding your own tagged photos of gear in the wild, writing reviews, recommending related/complementary gear, etc.
How would you propose quickly giving people a sense of what they're in for?
Thanks for the thoughtful response, gchiaren. :) I appreciate you asking.
I think the content below the scroll is a nice overview of what the EB experience is like, at the moment. It's evolving, as you mentioned, but those organized lanes/layers of artist and product content feel true to what is currently on-offer.
Naive/non-rhetorical question: do visitors who signup before exploring the site have better long-term outcomes than those who explore first, then signup at a later date/time? If so, then I'd say the new design makes perfect sense as-is. If the data suggests otherwise, I might suggest funneling them directly to the experience/activity that best correlates to a positive long-term outcomes, and having the signup wall present once they try to add a review, photo, like, etc.
For anyone reading along, most of the people who frequent Equipboard are way more fun than me, and they don't speak in boring software/business jargon like this. I'm an oddball. Someone say something FUN, please! XD